Showing posts with label John McCain. Show all posts
Showing posts with label John McCain. Show all posts

Saturday, November 1, 2008

Hong Kong, Russia and the Flat Tax

BOULDER, Colorado -- I may have been a little too hard on the flat tax in my last post. It is not an utterly bankrupt idea, but it is one that is usually floated as a populist ploy - it is popular because it is easy to understand, not because there is any real evidence supporting it.

Hong Kong's tax system is often cited as an example of either a flat tax or an "alternative minimum tax." In fact, it is neither; the system does have tax brackets with graduated rates, but at the highest income level, filers pay a flat rate of 16% with no deductions or credits. Hong Kong's system is admired because it is efficient and straightforward. Workers pay taxes on their income, and companies pay taxes on their profits. There are no additional levies like payroll or sales taxes, meaning the revenue stream is simple. As Alan Reynolds from the Cato Institute argues, even with the much lower rates in the Hong Kong system (ranging from 2% to 20%), government revenue would not be substantially lower if this system were adopted in the US. Hong Kong collects about 7% of GDP in income and profit taxes, while the US rate is 8-9%.

The arguments in favor of a purely flat tax system are far less convincing. It has really only been adopted by the former socialist countries of Eastern Europe, and there is little evidence to suggest that it has increased government revenue or attracted more investment. A simplified tax code just makes collection slightly easier in countries that are plagued by official corruption and low levels of compliance by taxpayers. Here is a list of the countries that currently have a flat tax system:

Albania
Bulgaria
Czech Republic
Estonia
Guernsey and Jersey
Kazakhstan
Iceland
Iraq
Kyrgyzstan
Latvia
Lithuania
Macedonia
Mongolia
Montenegro
Mauritius
Romania
Russia
Serbia
Slovenia
Gangster pseudo-state Transdnistria
Ukraine

And of course, John McCain's favorite country and Russia's whipping boy, the Republic of Georgia. Because today, my friends, we are all Georgians.

I don't know how I got onto this topic, as John McCain is certainly not a proponent of the flat tax; I just think it is a rather interesting debate. But it is unlikely that we will see any substantive changes in the tax code, regardless of who wins the presidency. The government will simply make slight changes to the brackets and rates of what is a pretty confusing and inefficient system.

Friday, October 31, 2008

Would You Like a Vice President With that 72-Year-Old Shake?

NEW YORK, NY -- Two Republican Party elders voiced support for Barack Obama today, part of a torrent of Republicans jumping ship.

Ken Duberstein, Reagan's chief of staff, endorsed Obama today, saying the following:

"I think it has very much undermined the whole question of John McCain’s judgment. You know what most Americans I think realized is that you don’t offer a job, let alone the vice presidency, to a person after one job interview. Even at McDonald’s, you’re interviewed three times before you get a job."












And Lawrence Eagleburger, secretary of state under Bush Sr. and a man whose support McCain has often touted, brought further pain today on NPR, where he said Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin was "of course" not ready to be vice president.

It seems unprecedented that so many grandees from one party should voice support for the other party's nominee. If McCain wins, it won't just be a rejection of Obama or the Democrats, but even of thinking Republicans including writers and party elders. It will be the true ascendancy of the idiocracy.

UPDATE:
House Minority Leader John Boehner. What a boner.

From the Miami University (Ohio) Miami Student newspaper: "Now, listen, I've voted 'present' two or three times in my entire 25-year political career, where there might have been a conflict of interest and I didn't feel like I should vote," Boehner said.

"In Congress, we have a red button, a green button and a yellow button, alright. Green means 'yes,' red means 'no,' and yellow means you're a chicken shit. And the last thing we need in the White House, in the oval office, behind that big desk, is some chicken who wants to push this yellow button."

Is this the first sign of the idiocracy?

Thursday, October 30, 2008

John McCain Doesn't Understand How Taxes Work

BOULDER, Colorado -- I first want to thank Itchy for his impassioned comments. I will be interested to hear what he thought about Barack's infomercial on Wednesday night. I was just a bit disappointed that it did not involve a voodoo stick and lots and lots of pie charts, like Ross "Now, lookee here ..." Perot back in 1992.

The more I think back to that campaign, the more staggering some of the similarities appear (minus the semi-viable, wing-nut, third-party candidate, of course). A critical difference, however, was that the Republican candidate who was running back then was actually a pretty competent steward of the economy. Though America was in the depths of a recession in the early 1990's, the Financial Institutions Reform, Recovery, and Enforcement Act of 1989 that George H.W. Bush signed into law is widely credited with staving off a much a longer and deeper financial crisis, and it set in place important regulations that allowed for the economic expansion of the Clinton years. The regulation came at a steep price, of course, in the form of new taxes, taxes which would ultimately cost Bush re-election after his famous "read my lips" pledge in 1988.

The differences between father and son are quite striking, and they should be pretty obvious to everyone. When it comes to competent management of the economy, the choice in this election should be abundantly clear - McCain wants to continue the bumbling, ideologically-driven, irresponsible policies of George W. Bush, and he would rather rely on poisonous populist rhetoric than put forward any concrete proposals. If you doubted the sheer depths of McCain's economic ignorance, read this quote from his interview on CNN's Larry King Live last night:

KING: You don't believe Barack Obama is a socialist, do you?

MCCAIN: No. But, I do believe -- I do believe that he's been in the far left of American politics. He has stated time after time that he believes in "spreading the wealth around." He's talked about courts that would redistribute the wealth.

...

KING: Concerning spreading the wealth, isn't the graduated income tax spreading the wealth? If you and I paid more so that Jimmy can get some for him, or pay for a welfare recipient, that's spreading the wealth.

MCCAIN: Well, that's spreading the wealth in the respect that we do have a graduated income tax. That's a far cry from taking from one group of Americans and giving to another. I mean, that's dramatically different.

Sen. Obama clearly has talked about for years, redistributive policies. And that's not the way we create wealth in America. That's not the way we grow our economy. That's not the way we create jobs.

Imagine that - a sensible question from Larry King. John McCain said outright that he does not really believe that Barack Obama is a socialist, but he is going to continue with this yarn regardless. The fact of the matter is that John McCain seems to reject the very notion of the graduated income tax, which is a position far more radical than returning to the tax rates of Clinton, H.W. Bush, and Reagan, as Obama proposes. There will always be some people who pay more into the system than they get out in the form of services from the government, and everybody accepts that. People's wealth is not entirely derived from the sweat of their brow; everybody reaps some benefits from society in the form of opportunities or collective services or common infrastructure, and we all agree that the people that take more out of the common stock should probably put a bit more in. Similarly, the people who have not benefited so much should probably pay a bit less. This is not socialism - it is called tax brackets, and no sensible person thinks that it is subversive or radical.

Instead, McCain implies that to be poor is to be lazy. He does not actually believe that we should eliminate the income tax, but he is using this rhetoric to appeal to the extreme right wing, people that subscribe to an ideology founded on irrational defense of the free market and perverse interpretation of individual freedom - I am referring to people who support ideas like libertarianism and the flat tax. These are radical ideas, and they should be rejected as readily as revolutionary communism.

So, John McCain is not a sensible person, and he should shut his damn mouth about socialism before he whips this country into another Red Scare. Hopefully the latest poll numbers indicate that his attacks are ringing more hollow by the day.

[Transcript of interview]

Wednesday, October 29, 2008

Is Obama a Marxist? Just Ask Old Himmler McCain

The "socialist" tack of the McCain campaign has really been annoying me, both because of its potential to seriously harm the hopes of either party normalizing its relationship with the other (can you, a red-blooded American congressman, really co-sponsor legislation with the Commies?) and because it is another step down the path of McCain/Rovian prevarication that cynically assumes voters are half-wit slobs to be lied to and manipulated (WHAT, WHAT, Leo Strauss!).

Its upshot is that McCain has somehow managed to link white American men's fears of black people (not to mention terrorists, both of the "washed-up" and homebred sort as well as of the more exotic Arab sort) with their fears of Communism, nothing to sniff at nearly 17 years after the collapse of the Soviet Union.

Obama has done too little to counter this claim, probably because he is too smart to take it seriously. However, I think any voter who can still be undecided at this point probably isn't quite as swift. Obama does need to get out his economic message more clearly tonight, to finally put the nail in McCain's coffin (before a heart attack does it a year into office), by forcefully making the following points:

1. Fully rebut the "Socialist" label: Obama needs to put this thing to rest already. Firstly, he should mention that the richest 2% would still be paying fewer taxes than under Reagan or Clinton and that government revenues from taxes as a percentage of GDP would be lower than under either of those presidents -- or under any president but Bush for that matter. He should most certainly not imply that anything even vaguely socialist is OK.

Obama needs to rebut clearly that he is a socialist and remind people with a bright yellow highlighter that taxes for the richest under Obama would be lower even than under Reagan or any other president besides Bush. If he's a socialist, so is Reagan, GHW Bush, Teddy Roosevelt and Eisenhower.

2. Explain fiscal responsibility and the irresponsibility (and break from American tradition) that Bush's tax cuts have represented. I think a large number of our countrymen no longer have any idea why taxes are necessary at all. This is a huge cognitive disconnect on the part of Americans springing from the fact that Bushian anti-government ideology has, I think, instilled in many a sense that government can just cut taxes ad infinitum and that history has a teleological purpose in getting taxes eventually down to zero, which would've happened years ago if it weren't for Communists masquerading as congressmen.

Obama needs to set out:

a) why government is at all necessary and why it has always been involved in certain aspects of American life (roads, schools, military) -- and why it has retreated from some of these in recent years with dire consequences (as in Katrina);

b) that taxes are therefore needed to restore the traditional place of government;

and that c) huge deficits and fiscal irresponsibility were fine for Bush when he squandered Clinton's surpluses but if the government isn't able to climb out of debt it'll raise interest rates for everyone and really hurt businesses (unlike marginal tax increases). Given that the Republicans have given up fiscal responsibility for those Pillars of Human Learning -- the issues of Creationism, Gun Control, Abortion and Sex Ed -- maybe the Democrats will take up the banner of fiscal prudence.

3. Name the people likely to be on his economic team: Although anyone who's concerned about Ayers or Wright is probably just using those arguments as a cover for racism, these absurd rumors persist, thanks to the Old Man and Twit who circulate them every day. Obama needs to show people that he is the centrist in this election, that any change he represents would act to restore -- not remake -- America, and he needs to do this by saying who his advisers are. When people see that familiar, trusted faces like Larry Summers, Paul Volcker, Robert Rubin and Warren Buffett are the crux of his team, it becomes harder to hold on to fantasies that he's an America-hating Muslim terrorist socialist.

A nice dig at McCain, whose economic advisers are a bunch of partisan hacks (Douglas Holtz-Eakin seems to be a political talking-head bulldog more than an economist); failed business leaders (Carly Fiorina was as apt an exec at H-P as Palin was an interviewee with Katie Couric, only Palin didn't cut 20,000+ US jobs or take a $21 million golden parachute after the interview; Meg Whitman's EBay has never even been profitable); and ideologues (the likes of Phil Gramm and Jack Kemp are Reagan political toadies with no claim to any experience or knowledge about economics at all), would be entirely appropriate here.

4. Give concrete details about job creation plans. Not only is job creation a huge worry for most voters (and rightly so), it's also an Obama strong suit. His job-creation strategies, admirably, are a mix of ideas from some of the world's smartest people. The creation of a $60 billion National Infrastructure Development Bank -- as conceived by Felix Rohatyn to oversee projects of federal, not local, importance -- and focusing on "rebuilding America" will be a huge source of jobs to do long-overdue work and avoid the local, "Bridge to Nowhere"-type projects Palin is fond of.

Obama already mentions his $150 billion "Manhattan Project" for energy independence and the greentech jobs it would bring -- 5 million jobs in building solar panels and turbines, and overhauling the nation's electrical grid -- in his stump, but he needs to do it even better.

His plans for public-private partnerships and investment funds to identify and develop advanced manufacturing techniques that would bring back production jobs to the US are hardly ever mentioned. Neither are the $80 billion in tax credits that would go to small/new businesses or R&D positions. Longer-term goals of worker-retraining, education and healthcare also play a part here...

McCain's plans, really, boil down to nothing more than giving the richest more tax breaks and increasing the house-of-cards aspects of our economy by further puffing up indecorous levels of consumer spending that far outpace production via tax cuts and low interest rates. This is called a consumer bubble; being the world's shopper of last resort, spending credit fueled by the Chinese Communist Party's investment in US bonds and not producing anything, will leave us in a hole much bigger than our current over-leveraged mess, given that real estate spending is a small fraction of overall consumer spending.

BONUS: Call McCain a racist Nazi slut. Conceding that the twin horrors of the 20th century were fascism and communism, if McCain's proxies can call Obama a "Marxist," the equivalent would be to call McCain a "Nazi." Of course, McCain's no Nazi, and Obama's no Marxist. But just as Obama wants to empower the middle class and bridge the wealth gap that is swallowing the country, so are McCain and Palin running a racially charged campaign about which candidate is true to "American culture" and "traditional American values" or, more simply put, is "American." That's as Nazi as Obama is Marxist, if not more so.

Tuesday, October 28, 2008

People Who Should Have Been Fired, But Haven't: Tucker Bounds

BOULDER, Colorado -- I had not seen this bobble-headed nitwit in weeks, so I had just assumed that McCain spokesman Tucker Bounds had been cut loose by the campaign. But he is still around, defending untrue robocalls and Reaganomics and repeating the Animal Farm-like argument that a vote for Obama is the equivalent to a "double down" on George W. Bush's economic and fiscal policies.

At least he said today that you probably should not vote for Ted Stevens (the same 200-year-old, massively corrupt senator who had endorsed Sarah Palin in the Alaska governor's race).

Ugh, I cannot wait for this election to be over so that I can get back to writing about bad journalism in Russia. It is not quite so depressing when the terrible, incompetent journalism isn't coming from your own country and doesn't have an impact on the most monumental election of a generation. But my friend gave me a few words of solace: "But I'll find the strength, and the darnkess shall not comprehend it."

In the meantime, go and cast your vote for Osama bin Lohan.